Caribbean Mahi Mahi Sandwiches with Chile Lime Slaw

If you’re craving something fresh, bold, and packed with sunshine flavor, these Caribbean Mahi Mahi Sandwiches with Chile Lime Slaw are a must-try and feature the premium products from our "Backyard BBQ Bliss" box.

Grilled mahi mahi fillets seasoned with Sauce Goddess’ Jamaican Jerk blend bring just the right balance of smoky heat and island spice. Layered on fluffy toasted brioche or Hawaiian buns, each sandwich is a flavor vacation waiting to happen.

The Perfect Sweet & Spicy Balance

The real magic of this recipe lies in the topping. A vibrant pineapple mango slaw adds juicy sweetness, crunch, and a citrusy brightness that pairs beautifully with the jerk-spiced fish. The creamy kick of Terrapin Ridge Farms’ Chile Lime Aioli ties it all together, delivering just enough tang and spice to keep you coming back for another bite. It’s the ultimate fusion of heat, sweet, and zest — exactly what you’d want in a tropical-inspired sandwich.

Quick, Easy & Crowd-Approved

With just 15 minutes of prep and a short grill time, this dish is weeknight-friendly yet impressive enough for entertaining. Whether you’re firing up the grill for a backyard cookout or just want to bring a little beachy vibe to your dinner table, these sandwiches hit the spot. Serve them with a side of grilled corn, crispy fries, or even a chilled tropical salad, and you’ve got a meal that’s both refreshing and satisfying.

BBQ

|

Grill or Flattop

Caribbean Mahi Mahi Sandwiches with Chile Lime Slaw

No ratings yet

Print RecipeShare recipe

Servings

4

Prep Time

15 minutes

Cook Time

10-12 minutes

These bold and beachy sandwiches feature perfectly grilled mahi mahi fillets seasoned with island-inspired jerk spices, tucked into toasted buns, and topped with a zesty, creamy chile lime slaw. The result is a vibrant balance of heat, brightness, and texture that delivers big Caribbean flavor in every bite.

Ingredients

• 2 Tbsp Jamaican Jerk Seasoning by Sauce Goddess
• Chile Lime Aioli Garnishing Squeeze by Terrapin Ridge Farms
• 4 Mahi Mahi Fillets (4–6 oz each)
• 1 Tbsp Olive Oil
• 4 Toasted Brioche or Hawaiian Buns

Pineapple Mango Slaw Ingredients

• 1 Cup Shredded Green Cabbage
• 1/2 Cup Shredded Carrots
• 1/2 Cup Diced Fresh Pineapple
• 1/2 Cup Diced Mango
• 2 Tbsp Chopped Cilantro
• 1 Tbsp Apple Cider Vinegar
• Juice of 1/2 Lime
• Salt to taste

Directions

1. Make the slaw: In a medium bowl, combine cabbage, carrots, pineapple, mango, cilantro, vinegar, lime juice, and salt. Mix well and let sit for 10–15 minutes while the fish cooks to allow flavors to meld.

2. Pat your mahi mahi fillets dry. Rub with olive oil, then coat generously with Jamaican Jerk Seasoning by Sauce Goddess on both sides.

3. Preheat your grill or griddle to medium-high heat. Grill mahi mahi for 4–6 minutes per side, or until the internal temperature reaches 140–145°F and the flesh flakes easily.

4. During the last 2–3 minutes of cooking, place the buns cut-side-down on the grill or griddle. Toast until golden brown and lightly crisp.

5. Assemble your sandwiches: Place grilled mahi mahi fillets on toasted buns. Top with a generous scoop of pineapple mango slaw and a light drizzle of Chile Lime Aioli.