Peppercorn-Crusted Tri-Tip with Garlic Mustard Finish
This Peppercorn-Crusted Tri-Tip recipe is one of the standout steakhouse-style recipes from our Bold & Braised box -- and proof that simple technique, when done right, delivers big results. This cook is built around the reverse-sear method, allowing you to gently bring the tri-tip up to temperature before finishing it over high heat for that deep, peppery crust. The result is edge-to-edge pink with a beautifully textured exterior.
The foundation of the flavor comes from Roasted Garlic Peppercorn Seasoning by Char Crust. As the name suggests, this blend is designed to form a signature crust that helps “Seals In the Juices®” during high-heat cooking. The roasted garlic brings savory depth, while cracked peppercorns add bite and complexity. During the low-and-slow stage, the seasoning bonds to the surface and begins forming that dark, steakhouse-style exterior. When you move the tri-tip over direct heat, the crust intensifies -- becoming bold, aromatic, and deeply satisfying without burning.
What really elevates this dish, though, is the finish. A drizzle of Creamy Garlic Mustard Sauce by Terrapin Ridge Farms adds richness and brightness that cuts through the beef’s natural fat. At first, mustard on steak might sound unconventional -- but this isn’t a sharp deli mustard. It’s creamy, tangy, and garlic-forward, with just enough acidity to balance the peppery crust. Instead of overpowering the beef, it enhances it, acting almost like a compound butter with a brighter edge.
This recipe captures the spirit of the Bold & Braised box: bold seasoning, controlled heat, and a confident finish. It’s elegant enough for a dinner party but simple enough for a weeknight grill session. Slice it properly against the grain, serve it with that silky yellow mustard sauce on the side, and you’ve got a steak experience that feels both refined and unmistakably built for the fire.
This reverse-seared tri-tip delivers bold steakhouse flavor with a peppercorn crust, juicy interior, and a rich garlic mustard finish that takes it over the top. Simple, elegant, and built for the grill.
Directions
Prep & Season: Pat tri-tip dry, trim excess silver skin, coat lightly with olive oil, and season generously on all sides with Roasted Garlic Peppercorn Seasoning by Char Crust, pressing seasoning into the meat.
Cook Low & Slow: Cook over indirect heat at 275°F on the grill or smoke at 250°F using oak or hickory until internal temperature reaches 115–120°F.
Sear for Crust: Move tri-tip to direct high heat (450–500°F) and sear 2–3 minutes per side until a deep crust forms, taking advantage of Char Crust’s signature “Seals In the Juices®” crust.
Rest & Finish: Pull tri-tip at 125–130°F for medium-rare, rest 10 minutes, slice against the grain, and finish with a drizzle of Creamy Garlic Mustard Sauce by Terrapin Ridge Farms.
Join 100,000+ Grill Masters
Get weekly recipes, pro tips, and exclusive deals sent straight to your inbox. Plus your free Pit Card download and 10% off your first order.
