GRATE DEALS: 20% Off Subscriptions - Click Here
Grill Masters Club
20% Off America's #1 BBQ Box 20% Off America's #1 BBQ Box
BEST SELLER 🔥 Boss of Burnt Ends Bundle - Order Now
Recipes & Guides

Not Just A Grilled Cheese Sandwich, But a Grilled, Grilled Cheese Sandwich

Recipes
https://youtu.be/RllWJUvrxEY
Ingredients
  1. 4 (1/2-inch slices) hearty country bread
  2. 3 ounces grated extra sharp cheddar cheese (Cabot)
  3. 1 ounce unsalted butter, at room temperature
  4. 1 teaspoon dry mustard
  5. 3 ounces grated Gruyere cheese
  6. 1/2 teaspoon smoked paprika
  7. 1/4 teaspoon freshly ground black pepper
Browse by Category
How to Smoke MeatAmerican BBQ StylesGrilling TechniquesBBQ Gear & Buying GuidesSauces Rubs & Flavor
Recipes Guides TipsAll
Recent Articles
Connect with Us

Leave a comment

Please note, comments must be approved before they are published.

RELATED POSTS

Hot Honey Blackened Chicken Sandwich with Williamson Bros & Blackened Seasoning
Hot Honey Blackened Chicken Sandwich
Hot Honey BBQ Burnt Ends
Hot Honey BBQ Burnt Ends
Burger press smashing a beef patty on a hot griddle for crispy-edged smash burgers
How to Make Smash Burgers: The Complete Guide to Crispy-Edged Smashburgers
How to Cook Chicken Wings: Crispy Grilled, Smoked & Flat Top Wings
How to Cook Chicken Wings: Crispy Grilled, Smoked & Flat Top Wings

Join Grill Masters Club

Premium sauces, rubs, and gear delivered to your door — plus original recipes and pro tips in every box.

Subscribe & Save Pay As You Go Give A Gift
Everything You Need for the Cook
🔥 BUILD YOUR OWN BBQ BUNDLE
Pick 5 for $49.99 or 10 for $89.99 with free shipping.

Subscribe & save 10%. Swap your picks every shipment. Build Your Bundle →
🔥 BUILD YOUR OWN BBQ BUNDLE

POPULAR PRODUCTS & BUNDLES

Shop our best-selling curated bundles with no subscription required.

on sale
3 Box Bundle Deal: 15 BBQ Products + Recipes and Tips3 Box Bundle Deal: 15 BBQ Products + Recipes and Tips
3 Box Bundle Deal: 15 BBQ Products + Recipes and Tips
4.9
Rated 4.9 out of 5 stars
16 Reviews
$139.99 $210.00
on sale
Smoker Essentials Bundle: XL BBQ Prep Tub, Resting Blanket, Grilling Gloves, Tongs + Lane's Signature Rub Product PhotoSmoker Essentials Bundle: Drip EZ Prep Tub + Resting Blanket + Grilling Gloves + Tongs + Free Rub
Smoker Essentials Bundle: Drip EZ Prep Tub + Resting Blanket + Grilling Gloves + Tongs + Free Rub
4.7
Rated 4.7 out of 5 stars
97 Reviews
$144.97 $169.99
on sale
The Grill Master's Platinum Bundle: Grilling Accessories for the Discerning Grill BossThe Grill Master's Platinum Bundle: Grilling Accessories for the Discerning Grill Boss
The Grill Master's Platinum Bundle: Grilling Accessories for the Discerning Grill Boss
5.0
Rated 5.0 out of 5 stars
4 Reviews
$224.99 $299.99
on sale
Backyard Pizza Accessory Bundle: Cast Iron Pizza Stone, Pizza Peel, Cutter + SauceBackyard Pizza Accessory Bundle: Cast Iron Pizza Stone, Pizza Peel, Cutter + Sauce
Backyard Pizza Accessory Bundle: Cast Iron Pizza Stone, Pizza Peel, Cutter + Sauce
5.0
Rated 5.0 out of 5 stars
2 Reviews
$147.97 $169.99
on sale
Mystery Grilling & BBQ Box: Sauces, Rubs, Tools + RecipesMystery Grilling & BBQ Box: Sauces, Rubs, Tools + Recipes
Mystery Grilling & BBQ Box: Sauces, Rubs, Tools + Recipes
4.9
Rated 4.9 out of 5 stars
46 Reviews
$49.99 $70.00
on sale
2 Box Bundle Deal for the Ultimate Grill Master2 Box Bundle Deal for the Ultimate Grill Master
2 Box Bundle Deal for the Ultimate Grill Master
5.0
Rated 5.0 out of 5 stars
22 Reviews
$89.99 $140.00
on sale
Baller Brisket Accessory Bundle: Prep Tub, Resting Blanket, Butcher Paper, Tallow + MoreBaller Brisket Accessory Bundle: Prep Tub, Resting Blanket, Butcher Paper, Tallow + More
Baller Brisket Accessory Bundle: Prep Tub, Resting Blanket, Butcher Paper, Tallow + More
4.8
Rated 4.8 out of 5 stars
5 Reviews
$187.97 $224.99

The Pitmaster Shop

Everything you need to make your BBQs the best on the block.

HOW IT WORKS

LEARN MORE ABOUT GRILL MASTERS CLUB

Discover our subscription and non-subscription options

Subscribe & Save

STARTING AT $36.99 PER DELIVERY

Prepay & save up to $167

Pay As You Go Subscriptions

GET STARTED FOR JUST $44.99 PER DELIVERY

Get 5+ products plus 8 original recipes & tips for $44.99 per box

Limited Release BBQ Boxes

5+ PRODUCTS PLUS ORIGINAL RECIPES & PRO TIPS

Shop past editions of The Ultimate BBQ Experience™ with FREE US SHIPPING

GIFT CARDS

CONVENIENTLY GIVE THE GIFT OF GREAT BBQ

Digital gift cards starting at just $50

BUILD YOUR OWN BBQ BUNDLE

5 PRODUCTS FOR $49.99 - FREE US SHIPPING

Create a bundle of premium, small-batch products

ACCESSORIES & TOOLS

GRILLING & SMOKING ACCESSORIES

Up your grill game with essentials like prep tubs, butcher's twine, grilling wraps & more

Pitmaster Curated Bundles

SAVE ON ESSENTIAL BBQ COMBOS

Premium grilling accessories bundled by our pitmasters

Give America's #1 Gift for Men

STARTING AT JUST $35.99 PER BOX

Give the BBQ gift that keeps on giving

BBQ Fuels

POWER YOUR GRILL WITH PREMIUM FUELS

Fuel your fire with Knotty Wood pellets and smoking chunks and chips - FREE US SHIPPING!

HOT SAUCES

BRING THE HEAT

Shop premium sauces from Bravado Spice Co, Alchemy Peppers, Underwood Ranches & more

Sauces & Rubs

PREMIUM, SMALL-BATCH SAUCES & SPICES

Products you won't find in your local grocery store