20% Off America's #1 Gift Box

20% Off America's #1 Gift Box

Recipes & Guides

1836 Tomahawk Ribeye Recipe

1836 Tomahawk Ribeye Recipe

Jun 27, 2024

A Tomahawk is one of the best cuts of steak out there. To maximize depth of flavor, the best way to prepare it is the reverse sear method.

Featuring Sucklebusters 1836 Beef Rub from our "Low & Slow, Bro" BBQ box.

1836 Tomahawk Recipe

Rated 4.0 stars by 1 users

Category

Smoker or Grill

Cuisine

BBQ

Servings

2-4

Prep Time

10 minutes

Cook Time

1 hour

A Tomahawk is one of the best cuts of steak out there. To maximize depth of flavor, the best way to prepare it is the reverse sear method.

Featuring Sucklebusters 1836 Beef Rub from our "Low & Slow, Bro" BBQ box!

Author:

Pitmaster Rosalie Pareja

Image of 1836 Tomahawk Recipe

Ingredients

Sucklebusters 1836 Beef Rub
1 Tomahawk Steak
2 Tbsp Butter
1 sprig of Rosemary

View Cart (0) Checkout

Directions

Preheat your smoker to 200 °F.
Season tomahawk steak with Sucklebusters 1836 Beef Rub. No binder needed.
Smoke at 200 °F for 45 minutes to 1 hour, until reaching an internal temp of 110 °F.
Remove the steak and increase the grill temperature to somewhere around 375-450 °F or on a burner on medium-high. We love to use a cast iron griddle, however searing directly on the grill grate works well too.
Remove the streak at 130-132 °F internal temperature. Add two Tbsp butter and a sprig of rosemary. Cover with foil and let rest.
Slice the meat off the bone and serve!

Recipe Note

Pro Tips: Cut the ribeye into sections. You will find a cap running along the sides of the ribeye, called the spinalis. Separate the spinalis first, then cut the tail off, separating the eye or filet of the ribeye, also known as the longissimus dorsi. By cutting the ribeye into proper sections, you’ll be able to taste the unique parts of the steak!

Browse by Category

How to Smoke Meat American BBQ Styles Grilling Techniques BBQ Gear & Buying Guides Sauces Rubs & Flavor

Recipes Guides Tips All

Recent Articles

Sticky Peach Habanero BBQ Wings

Some BBQ flavors are so good they leave a mess behind,...
Peach Habanero Pig Shots Recipe

As featured in our July/August "Sticky Situation" Box Some bites are...
"Sticky Situation" Box Overview

Table of Contents [hide] The Ultimate BBQ Experience: Sticky Situation...

Connect with Us

Leave a comment

RELATED POSTS

Recommended For This Post

Hand-picked BBQ gear and flavor to go with what you just read.

Pappy & Company Bourbon Barrel Stave Smoking Chunks (5 lb)

Pappy & Company Bourbon Barrel Stave Smoking Chunks (5 lb)

Pappy & Company Bourbon Barrel Stave Smoking Chunks (5 lb)

$48.95

on sale

100% Natural Paraguayan Hardwood Lump Charcoal by FireForge Cooking (17.8 lb)

100% Natural Paraguayan Hardwood Lump Charcoal by FireForge Cooking (17.8 lb)

100% Natural Paraguayan Hardwood Lump Charcoal by FireForge Cooking (17.8 lb)

$36.99 ~~$46.99~~

100% Pure Almond Wood Splits by Knotty Wood (46-50lb)

100% Pure Almond Wood Splits by Knotty Wood (46-50lb)

100% Pure Almond Wood Splits by Knotty Wood (46-50lb)

5.0

Rated 5.0 out of 5 stars

1 Review

$44.99

on sale

100% Pure Almond Wood Barbecue Pellets by Knotty Wood (20lb)

100% Pure Almond Wood Barbecue Pellets by Knotty Wood (20lb)

100% Pure Almond Wood Barbecue Pellets by Knotty Wood (20lb)

5.0

Rated 5.0 out of 5 stars

2 Reviews

$19.86 ~~$24.48~~

on sale

2-Pack: 100% Pure Almond Wood Barbecue Pellets by Knotty Wood (2 x 20lb)

2-Pack: 100% Pure Almond Wood Barbecue Pellets by Knotty Wood (2 x 20lb)

2-Pack: 100% Pure Almond Wood Barbecue Pellets by Knotty Wood (2 x 20lb)

$39.72 ~~$48.96~~

on sale

Pellet Pro Bundle: 2-Pack Almond Pellets (40 lbs) + High-Temp BBQ Gloves

Pellet Pro Bundle: 2-Pack Almond Pellets (40 lbs) + High-Temp BBQ Gloves

Pellet Pro Bundle: 2-Pack Almond Pellets (40 lbs) + High-Temp BBQ Gloves

$63.99 ~~$78.95~~

on sale

Almond Wood BBQ Pellets (20lb) + Knotty Rub (12 oz) by Knotty Wood

Almond Wood BBQ Pellets (20lb) + Knotty Rub (12 oz) by Knotty Wood

Almond Wood BBQ Pellets (20lb) + Knotty Rub (12 oz) by Knotty Wood

$29.49 ~~$39.47~~

The Pitmaster Shop

Everything you need to make your BBQs the best on the block.

HOW IT WORKS

LEARN MORE ABOUT GRILL MASTERS CLUB

Discover our subscription and non-subscription options

Subscribe & Save

STARTING AT $39.99 PER DELIVERY

Prepay & save up to $167

Pay As You Go Subscriptions

GET STARTED FOR JUST $44.99 PER DELIVERY

Get 5+ products plus 8 original recipes & tips for $44.99 per box

Limited Release BBQ Boxes

5+ PRODUCTS PLUS ORIGINAL RECIPES & PRO TIPS

Shop past editions of The Ultimate BBQ Experience™ with FREE US SHIPPING

GIFT CARDS

CONVENIENTLY GIVE THE GIFT OF GREAT BBQ

Digital gift cards starting at just $50

BUILD YOUR OWN BBQ BUNDLE

5 PRODUCTS FOR $49.99 - FREE US SHIPPING

Create a bundle of premium, small-batch products

ACCESSORIES & TOOLS

GRILLING & SMOKING ACCESSORIES

Up your grill game with essentials like prep tubs, butcher's twine, grilling wraps & more

Pitmaster Curated Bundles

SAVE ON ESSENTIAL BBQ COMBOS

Premium grilling accessories bundled by our pitmasters

Give America's #1 Gift for Men

STARTING AT JUST $35.99 PER BOX

Give the BBQ gift that keeps on giving

BBQ Fuels

POWER YOUR GRILL WITH PREMIUM FUELS

Fuel your fire with Knotty Wood pellets and smoking chunks and chips - FREE US SHIPPING!

HOT SAUCES

BRING THE HEAT

Shop premium sauces from Bravado Spice Co, Alchemy Peppers, Underwood Ranches & more

Sauces & Rubs

PREMIUM, SMALL-BATCH SAUCES & SPICES

Products you won't find in your local grocery store

Cart